Davina portrait Oct 26Mauritius trapped between ‘Opportunistic Criminality’ and ‘Armchair Activism’

By Dr Davina Murden

On Friday, 9 October 2026, Elodie Thomas, a woman returning home from work, was reportedly shot by a police officer at around 10 pm. In the aftermath of this incident, small, scattered groups of individuals set fire to police stations to express their frustration. That frustration extended to the government in which public trust appears to be gradually eroding. These incidents soon escalated into acts of ‘opportunistic criminality’. Meanwhile, many Mauritians took to their online platforms to demand the resignation of the Prime Minister, Honourable Dr Navin Ramgoolam, resulting in a state of ‘armchair activism’. This analysis seeks to demonstrate how ‘opportunistic criminality’ and ‘armchair activism’ have come to dominate the public response, allowing deeper sources of social distress such as the erosion of trust in the government and persistent socio-economic challenges affecting ordinary Mauritians, to surreptitiously take centre stage.

The recurrence of riots

Mauritius is often regarded as one of the most peaceful countries on the African continent. One of the most significant episodes of civil unrest in the country’s history occurred in 1999, following the death of the seggae singer Joseph Reginald Topize, known as Kaya. His death triggered widespread riots across the island, with lasting social consequences, including the stigmatisation of the ‘Creole’ community.

As much as Mauritius is often praised for its ethnic, cultural and religious tolerance, uncomfortable realities exist. Mauritians rarely discuss these openly, partly because of the fragility of the country’s social fabric. As of 2026, Indo-Mauritians, whose ancestors originated in India, constitute the largest population group, accounting for approximately 68 per cent of the population. They are followed by the Creoles, who have predominantly African and Malagasy ancestry and account for approximately 27 per cent, Sino-Mauritians, whose ancestors originated in China, at 3 per cent, and Franco-Mauritians, who are of French descent, at 2 per cent. However, despite being regarded as the only ‘true Mauritians’, Creoles have historically experienced significant marginalisation, a phenomenon known as the ‘Malaise Créole’. ‘Le Malaise Créole’ is an umbrella concept that describes the persistent marginalisation of Creoles due to the Indo-Mauritian political and economic dominance. Nevertheless, it is worth pointing out that Mauritius has made significant progress to address this marginalisation, the most important ones being the Truth and Justice Commission (TJC) established in 2009 and the Equal Opportunities Commission (EOC) created in 2012. On the one hand, the TJC investigated the historical and socioeconomic consequences of slavery and indentured labour, recommending measures to address historical injustices. On the other hand, the EOC was established to combat discrimination, investigate complaints and promote equal opportunities under the Equal Opportunities Act 2008.

Yet, some segments of the Creole community appear to continue to experience marginalisation, particularly in the aftermath of the shooting of Elodie Thomas, who like Kaya, is from the Creole community. Although some internet users have alleged that members of the Creole community were responsible for setting fire to police stations following Thomas’ shooting, no reliable data or scientific research currently substantiates these claims. Nevertheless, the public discourse surrounding these events highlights the persistence of the ‘Le Malaise Créole’ phenomenon.

From Arson to ‘opportunistic criminality’

Prior to the Thomas shooting, there have been revolts against water shortages. These intensified after that regrettable incident. Since the beginning of 2025, the Minister of Energy and Public Utilities, Patrick Assirvaden, warned of the risk of water stress. During the first week of October 2026, the Mauritius Meteorological Services announced that the main reservoir providing water, Mare aux Vacoas, was only at 35.9 per cent. Consequently, the Central Water Authority (CWA), which is responsible for water supply, was forced to interrupt or restrict distribution in several regions. This prompted a number of protests in various localities. In response, the CWA indicated that a water-supply schedule would be introduced to help residents plan their consumption. However, some regions continued to experience water shortages, prompting further protests. As tensions mounted, police officers were deployed across Mauritius to help manage the situation. This provides context for the police presence when Thomas was shot.

The burning of police stations in some areas reflected the anger of the population over the rising costs of living and the water crisis. Although unlawful, these acts of destruction can be understood as the first phase of unrest, during which some individuals expressed their frustration with the government and demanded justice for Thomas. However, a second phase soon emerged, characterised by what can be described as ‘opportunistic criminality’. This type of crimes occur when the perpetrators take advantage of a chaotic situation to commit acts of vandalism such as destroying public and private properties. In Mauritius, a group of individuals reportedly consisting predominantly of young people, took advantage of the unrest to engage in looting of supermarkets, breaking into shops such as iStores, and attacking a truck transporting alcoholic beverages worth around Rs 350,000, among other incidents.

Such acts of ‘opportunistic criminality’ do not advance the pursuit of a Mauritius that upholds democratic values and protects socio-economic rights. Instead, they portray a group of individuals exploiting the disorder to engage in criminal activities that undermine the very society whose grievances initially fuelled the protests.

A growing culture of ‘armchair activism’

As its name suggests, ‘armchair activism’ is activism initiated from an armchair, at the comfort of one’s home, on online social media platforms. While ‘armchair activism’ is not inherently objectionable, passionately taking to the internet may be insufficient to challenge structural and systemic barriers present in a political system. Therefore, at some point, transitioning from ‘armchair activism’ to in-person protests may be necessary to bring about meaningful change within a political system. Closer to home, Madagascar offers an example of this transition. Before the 2025 ‘coupvolution’ in Madagascar, ‘armchair activism’ was mainly driven by Gen Z Mada, a youth-led online movement on Facebook and Tiktok, to revolt against poor access to basic necessities. However, this online activism soon spilled into the streets. The demonstrations subsequently drew the military into the unfolding political crisis, culminating in a coup d’état that ousted President Rajoelina.

In Mauritius, by contrast, much of the public response remains concentrated on social media where users advocate for socio-economic rights and democratic values, expressing their concerns most visibly and vocally during periods of crisis. However, when tensions subside, such engagement often becomes less visible, particularly on social media. This raises questions about the ability of citizens to maintain collective action beyond moments of crisis and, most importantly, the extent to which Mauritians have come to normalise the shortcomings of their democracy.

Some extra miles to go

Mauritius is caught between ‘opportunistic criminality’, which fuels public panic, and ‘armchair activism’, which highlights pressing issues such as the lack of political accountability and inadequate socioeconomic rights. However, the online mobilisation will unfortunately not be enough if there is no actual in-person and organised protests happening. In such cases, questions remain mostly unanswered, and there is no central point where all Mauritians can come together and publicly confront the government. This also shows that Mauritians in general have the ability to think and bring on board political ideas, but there is no institutionalised platform and proper mechanism to put these into practice. Also, the way in which the social tensions between different ethnic groups in Mauritius were reignited reveals that some groups, particularly the Creoles, continue to be victims of stigmatisation despite the existing institutional and legal frameworks. This underscores the significant gaps that remain to be addressed before Mauritius can consider ethnic tensions a thing of the past.

Dr Davina Murden is a Mauritian researcher in the fields of constitutionalism, the African human rights system, democracy and public participation processes.